Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Mr. White's method of disputation: part 2 - misdirection and sophistry


In reference to my assessment that Mr. White was inaccurate concerning his claim that, "In the early Church, as was mentioned before, the difference between homoousios and homoiousios is, is a HUGE* gap", just past the 22 minute mark in his DL response, he states:

And so he starts off taking on, now this is ,this a a statement that I did not come up with, this is a statement that many people far, far more trained in Church history than David Waltz could ever pretend to be, uhhh, have likewise stated.

Now, not one of the "many people far, far more trained in Church History" are either named, and/or cited—not one. With this in mind, note what the following scholars had to say about this issue:

Dr. Khaled Anatolios:

He [Athanasius] also concedes that those who follow the "likeness of essence" terminology of Basil Ancyra are substantially in accord with his own (Nicene) teaching, though he continues to prefer homoousios. We find similar conciliatory moves in Hilary of Poitier's On the Trnity, written in the early 360s. Hilary was careful to interpret homoousios in a way that clarified the real distinction between Father and Son, thus avoiding the specter of modalism, and was even more explicit than Athanasius in allowing the legitimacy of homoiousios. (Retrieving Nicaea, 2011, pp. 22, 23.)

Dr. G.W.H. Lampe:

This term [homoiousios] became characteristic of the theology of Basil of Ancyra, George bishop of Laodicea, and others who, while still anxious not to compromise the distinctness of the two hypostases, were moving nearer to the Nicene position in the face of the developed Arianism of the 'Anomoeans'. A formula drawn up in 359 by George of Laodicea asserted a likeness in substance between the Father and the Son as distinct hypostases and identity of deity. At about this same time Athanasius explicitly recognized that this party shared his own view, differing only in respect of their hesitation over the actual term homoousion; if they were content to acknowledge that the Son is both 'of like substance' with the Father and of the Father's substance [which they in fact did affirm], they were in agreement with the homoousion was intended to signify. (A History of Christian Doctrine, edited by H. Cunliffe -Jones, 1978, pp. 110, 111.)

[Note: Dr. Lampe is the author of the massive (1,568 pages) , and invaluable work, A Patristic Greek Lexicon.]

Dr. Jarsolav Pelikan:

But among nonscriptural words, what was so sacrosanct about homoousios? Athanasius, for example, made surprisingly little use of it and wrote his longest defense of the concept, the three Orations against the Arians, almost without mentioning it. And at the very end of his treatise on the councils, Hilary, "calling the God of heaven, and earth to witness," swore that he had not so much as heard of the Council of Nicea until he was about to go into exile in 356, but that he regarded homoousios and homoiousios as synonymous. They were not synonymous to begin with, but they eventually converged—not principally through orthodox suasions, but through the recognition by the adherents of both terms that the threat to what they believed most deeply was coming from the extreme Arian position: Christ the Logos was "unlike the Father" or, more moderately, "like the Father not in ousia." Speaking doctrinally rather than polictically, the homousios was saved by the further clarification of the unresolved problems of the One and the Three and by the recognition of a common religous concern between the partisans of homoousios and homoiousios. The spokemans for that recognition, after various kinds of hesitations, was Athanasius himself, who ultimately asserted his unwillingness to attack Homoiousians "as Ariomaniacss, or as opponents of the fathers; but we discuss the issue with them as brethren with brethren, who mean what we mean and are disputing only about terminology." (The Christian Tradition - The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition (100-600), 1971, p. 210.)

Dr. Henry Chadwick:

During the mid-4th century, a number of the largest and most important churches were being taken over by Arian bishops who were pressing the notion that:

...the Son is not merely distinct from the Father , but actually belongs to the created order; that all derived being is substantially dissimilar from the underived First Cause; in short, that the Son's essence is unlike (anomoios) the Father's. This position, quickly labled Anomoean or 'dissimilarian', was opposed not merely to the Nicene formula that the essence of the Father and the Son is identical (homoousios), but also to the predominant formula of the great majority of Greek bishops that the Son's essence is 'like' the Father's (homoiousios) as a perfect image resembles its archtype. This homoiousios formula seemed to possess the attractions that it affirmed the highest degree of resemblance short of that 'identity of essence' which, under the umbrella of the Nicene creed, could give dangerous protection to 'Sabellians' like Marcellus of Ancyra. (The Early Church, 1967, p. 141).

In 360 Athanasius realized Basil of Ancyra [a homoiousian] and he were basically fighting for the same cause, and held out a proposal of an alliance even if Basil and his friends retained their scruples about the keyword of the Nicene formula, 'identical in essence' (homoousios) : 'Those who accept the Nicene creed but have doubts about the term homoousios must not be treated as enemies; we discuss the matter with them as brothers with brothers; they mean the same as we, and dispute only about the word.' (Ibid. p. 144.)

Dr. J.W. Nevin:

These zealous teachers [the Anomoeans (i.e. Arians)], Eunomius in particular, had much to say of the absolute simplicity of the Divine nature, the being of God conceived of in the most abstract way, which made it impossible, they contended, that his substance could be conveyed by any generation to another; the Son could not be, therefore, absolutely like the Father, but must be regarded as the production of the Father's will out of nothing, though endowed with power to create the world, and exalted far above all other creatures. Such was the thinking and reasoning of the strict Arians. Over and against these stood the far larger party of the Semi-Arians of Homoiousians, sometimes called Eusebians, from their distinguishing representative, Eusebius of Cesarea, an unsteady fluctuating party, which felt itself pressed continually between the Arian and Nicene schemes of thought without the power of finding any firm middle ground of its own on which to stand. They contributed in truth little to the movement of theological thought. Their concern all the time was to maintain the distinction between the Father and the Son, which they supposed must fall away, if both were allowed to be of one substance [i.e. Sabellianism/monarchian modalism]...Finding itself thus hard pushed between on both sides, the party was led more and more through the force of its religious instincts, to disown Arianism and make common cause with the Nicene Faith, until, finally, having become reconciled to it at all points, it ceased to exist altogether. Indeed, Semi-nicene, rather than Semi-arian would seem to have been the proper title for the party from the first. ("Arianism", in the Mercersburg Review, vol. 14-1867, p. 438 - bold emphasis mine.)

[Note: Dr. Nevin was the good friend and colleague of the famous historian, Dr. Philip Schaff.]

Dr. Archibald Robertson:

We must now take account of the party headed by Basil of Ancyra and usually (since Epiphanius), but with some injustice, designated as Semi-Arians. Their theological ancestry and antecedents have been already sketched (pp. xxvii., xxxv.) ; they are the representatives of that conservatism, moulded by the neo-Asiatic, or modified Origenist tradition, which warmly condemned Arianism at Nicæa, but acquiesced with only half a heart in the test by which the Council resolved to exclude it. They furnished the numerical strength, the material basis so to call it, of the anti-Nicene reaction ; but the reaction on their part had not been Arian in principle, but in part anti-Sabellian, in part the empirical conservatism of men whose own principles are vague and ill-assorted, and who fail to follow the keener sight which distinguishes the higher conservatism from the lower. They lent themselves to the purposes of the Eusebians (a name which ought to be dropped after 342) on purely negative grounds and in view of questions of personal rights and accusations. A positive doctrinal formula they did not possess. But in the course of years reflexion did its work. A younger generation grew up who had not been taught to respect Nicæa, nor yet had imbibed Arian principles.  Cyril at Jerusalem, Meletius at Antioch, are specimens of a large class. The Dedication Creed at Antioch represents an early stage in the growth of this body of conviction, conviction not absolutely uniform everywhere, as the result shews, but still with a distinct tendency to settle down to a formal position with regard to the great question of the age. There was nothing in the Nicene doctrine that men like this did not hold : but the word ὁμοούσιος opened the door to the dreaded Sabellian error : was not the history of Marcellus and Photinus a significant comment upon it ? But if οὐσία meant not individuality, but specific identity (supr., p. xxxi. sq.) even this term might be innocently admitted. But to make that meaning plain, what was more effective than the insertion of an iota ? Ὁμοιούσιος, then, was the satisfactory test which would banish Arius and Marcellus alike. (Select Writings and Letters of Athanasius, Bishop of Alexandria, NPNF 4.lv.)

Anatolios, Lampe, Pelikan, Chadwick, Nevin, and Robertson (all recognized scholars of the period we are discussing), clearly side with my assessment, contra Mr. White, and his unnamed "many people far, far more trained in Church History".

I did not quote any of the above scholars in my original post, but rather, I quoted directly from St. Athanasius. Mr. White implies that I quoted St. Athanasius out of context, and urges his followers to read St. Athanasius for themselves. I will second that—everyone interested in this issue should read St. Athansius for themselves, for an objective reading of him in context will yield but one result, namely that St. Athanasius did not believe that,"the difference between homoousios and homoiousios is, is a HUGE* gap", and will instead affirm with Dr. Lampe, myself, and others, that "Athanasius explicitly recognized that this party shared his own view, differing only in respect of their hesitation over the actual term homoousion".

Interestingly enough, St. Athanasius himself had no problem with the terms "likeness" and "like":

We understand in like manner that the Son is begotten not from without but from the Father, and while the Father remains whole, the Expression of His Subsistence is ever, and preserves the Father's likeness and unvarying Image, so that he who sees Him, sees in Him the Subsistence too, of which He is the Expression. (Contra Arianos 2.33 - NPNF 4.366.)

And:

For what is sown in every soul from the beginning is that God has a Son, the Word, the Wisdom, the Power, that is, His Image and Radiance; from which it at once follows that He is always ; that He is from the Father; that He is like ; that He is the eternal offspring of His essence ; and there is no idea involved in these of creature or work. (Contra Arianos 2.34- NPNF 4.366.)

So, once again, concerning Mr. White's bold statement that,"In the early Church, as was mentioned before, the difference between homoousios and homoiousios is, is a HUGE* gap": Is that an accurate statement?


Grace and peace,

David

[*Note: Mr. White took issue with the fact that I placed his "HUGE" statement in all capitals; I did so because in the NCE-E1 video he significantly emphasized "HUGE" by a prolonged elongation of it's pronouncement. I could have of chosen to have used 'huuuuuuuuuuge', instead of HUGE, but selected the latter.]

Saturday, September 1, 2012

Mr. White's method of disputation: part 1 - 'poisoning the wells', and abusing a Reformed Baptist missionary


Thanks to Ken Temple over at Beggars All (LINK), I found out yesterday that James R. White responded to my previous two blog posts on last Thursday's Dividing Line program (LINK). I am using "responded" quite loosely—diatribe and/or rant would be a more precise description. As an introduction of sorts to what Mr. White had to say (he stated in the program that I do not have the right to call him James—yes, I know, quite petty), I am going to adapt something that John Henry Newman penned to one of his critics:

I scorn and detest lying, and quibbling, and double-tongued practice, and slyness, and cunning, and smoothness, and cant, and pretence, quite as much as any Christians hate them ; and I pray to be kept from the snare of them. But all this is just now by the bye ; my present subject is Mr. White ; what I insist upon here, now that I am addressing this portion of my discussion to the opening comments he made concerning me on the August 30, 2012 Dividing Line program, is this unmanly attempt of his, to cut the ground from under my feet ;—to poison by anticipation the public mind against me, and to infuse into the imaginations of my readers, suspicion and mistrust of every thing that I may say in reply to him. This I call poisoning the wells. (Adapted from John Henry Newman's, Mr. Kingsely's Method Of Disputation.)

Mr. White stated (10:20ff.):

David Waltz is one of my stalkers...has been for over a decade.

This is not the first time that Mr. White has leveled this charge in my direction. Back in 2009, I responded to this silly accusation in three threads:




[Mr. White's most recent recipient of "stalking" appears to be Dr. William Lane Craig.]

Mr. White continued with:

I don't even bother reading his stuff, because when it comes to me, all he does is follow me around try to find something to uhh, to pick on. Try to find something to, to make him look like he's smart and I am stupid.

This is utterly false. I have never been to his Twitter account; I look in on his blog a couple of times a month to see if he has posted something that pertains to one of my interests; I wrote a letter to CRI a few years back that addressed an article he wrote on Islam in their journal; I sometimes drop by his chat room at night when I have trouble sleeping (maybe 5 or 6 times over the last year), but I have never commented on anything he writes there; I rarely listen to his Dividing Line—fact is, the majority of cases of when I read or listen to him is when one of his devoted followers provides a link to something he said or wrote.

Mr. White:

And normally it is some kind of juhh [?], it uhh, the definition of nit picking, and that's what we have here today. Now one of my, my, one of the reasons I, I—to be perfectly honest with you, I don't bother reading the man, that is because he is the quintessential definition of the person who is blown about by every wind of doctrine. He's been everything.

Wow, he doesn't bother reading what I write, but he somehow 'knows' that I have "been everything". Eerie, scary...

Mr. White:

I haven't been keeping track ummm, my recollection is he was once Jehovah's Witness; he's been uhhh, he's played around with Roman Catholicism; and he's into Orthodoxy; he's just (whistles), just all over the place.

Right...I was born into, and raised a JW (4th generation—no choice in that—eternal decree of God); left the JW's in 1983 after 8 years of intense study and prayer;  joined the Orthodox Presbyterian Church via baptism on March 25, 1984 through the influence of my Greek  tutor and theological mentor; started having serious doubts about the Reformed faith in the early 90s due to the number of denominational splits that occurred among conservative adherents, with our Lord's prayer to the Father in John 17 weighing heavily on my mind; on March 30, 2002, I entered the RCC via confirmation and first communion after years of in depth study and prayer; and finally, I ceased attending the RCC and mass at the beginning of 2010 due to critical issues I elaborated on here at AF. Have never been a member of any other church/denomination other than the three listed above. Yeah, I have "been everything", "just all over the place"...BTW Mr. White, how many different denominations have you been a member of ???


Mr. White:

And you know, I have, I'll be honest, I have a real hard time working up a whole lot of respect for people who are blown about by every wind of doctrine. And, and they can't get their feet down on the ground and stay in one place [can you spell Southern Baptist Convention] for long enough to actually accomplish anything, and so it's easy for him to sit around—he's a moving target—'cuzz phew, because today and next week he might believe (some jumbled word I can't understand followed by laughing) that's pretty easy. Uhh, uhh, that's an easy way to get around things.

My-oh-my...what was that all about? Weird...

Mr. White: But uhh, he's very proud of his very large library...

Yes I am. I am a bibliophile—have been since I was about 4 years old—it has taken me over 50 years to build my library, so yes, I am somewhat "proud" of it. But then, Mr. White has commented on his large library in the past (not only the size, but also the expense, with a number of the books costing hundreds of dollars each), and he too seems quite proud of it—ahhh, the joy of double-standards...

Mr. White: ...and uhh, so he sits around dragging quotations out and firing and stuff.

Do you have a hidden camera in my library Mr. White ???

Now, the whole reason again that I, I'm going to address this is uhh, as I said, B1Crowley [spelling?] on Twitter sent me the link after I had already heard about it from TurretinFan; I had told TurretinFan, "what's, what's he up to now". "He's, he's talking about some things you said in the No Compromise video. I said, "oh, about modalism?" "Yeah, you're misrepresenting the Oneness guys and stuff like that." So once it was Tweeted to me, I thought, OK, alright, let's take a look at what he has to say.

Wow, quite the introduction, for sure. We have the quintessential 'poisioning the wells' fallacy displayed via character assassination, ad hominems, wild conjecture and outright falsehoods. What an ensemble !!!

Though the derogatory comments and insults do not end here, at least Mr. White finally starts to comment (well, sort-of) on what I posted—from 21:04 ff.:

Alright, so, the first article uhh was posted uhh yesterday, "James R. White: you should have stayed out of 'the deep water'." I just love this (chuckles), the, the Waltz is, does not make any pretense to humility, uhh and he talks about someone taking a pot-shot at Carl Trueman, and uhh, well not everyone at the Council of Nicea was Turks, and , and basically what these guys want to do is they, they sit around going, "look how smart I am about Church history, I'm smarter than that person there. I can disagree with you, I can nit-pick anything." That's what these guys are. It's like they never leave their, their libraries to do anything else. And I don't think David Waltz has ever actually debated a Oneness person, or actually gone out in the front-lines and done it like that. They sit in the back and toss stones and go look how smart I am.

Yes, the pettiness and 'poisoning the wells' continues; but now, Mr. White includes a fellow Reformed Baptist in the mix. Those who are following this series of threads on Mr. White know that the "someone taking a pot-shot at Carl Trueman" is none other than Ken Temple.

Now, a couple of important points: first, I do not think at all that Ken was "taking a pot-shot at Carl Trueman", in fact, I believe that he had some very valid points concerning certain statements made by Dr. Trueman in the NCE-E1 video; second, Ken is an SBC missionary who focuses on Iranian Muslims who live in America—I think it is safe to say that Ken doesn't just, "sit around going, 'look how smart I am about Church history, I'm smarter than that person there'," as Mr. White charges.

On a side note, I find it more than just a bit interesting that Mr. White is "taking a pot-shot at" at Ken, for not only is Ken a fellow Reformed Baptist, he is also a major contributor at the Beggars All blog, which is owned by James Swan, who is a member of Mr. White's "Team Apologian". I guess 'collateral damage' has little meaning to Mr. White.

I shall end part 1 here; probably will not be able to start working on part 2 until Monday—the Lord willing.


Grace and peace,

David

Thursday, August 30, 2012

James R. White: you should have stayed out of "the deep water" - part 2


At the 13:30 ff. mark of the NCE-E1 video linked to in my previous thread, James White said:

And it would be very easy—would have been absolutely simplistic—to, to press T. D. Jakes to come up with a meaningful response to one simple question—which I would think would be just obvious to a church leader at least—uhh, and that is this: Did the Son as a divine person pre-exist his birth in Bethlehem? Not as an ideal idea; not as, as concept in the mid of the Father; but, did the Son as a divine person exist prior to his birth in Bethlehem? Did he have interaction with the Father...

And a bit later at 15:00 ff.:

All you have to do to recognize modalism, and to, and to unmask modalism, is to, is to say: Do you believe that the Son as a divine person pre-existed his birth in Bethlehem? Was in relationship with the Father; there was communion and love between the Son and the Father before the incarnation. That question was not asked.

I discern two significant problems with the above comments by James: first, modalists believe "the one Being that is God" (I am using James' own phrase, from his book The Forgotten Trinity, here) pre-existed His incarnation, "as Father, Word, and Spirit." James' "absolutely simplistic" question is easily side-stepped by historic/traditional modalists. Second, a number of Evangelical theologians (including Reformed folk) deny that the second person of the Trinity existed as the Son prior to the incarnation !!! (See THIS THREAD for documentation.)

Maybe it was just on 'off-day' for James (I sincerely hope that in his debates with modalists his arguments were substantially more accurate and solid); but with that said, I shall end this post by recommending that a good portion of his presentation in the NCE-E1 video should be Forgotten as soon as possible...


Grace and peace,

David

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

James R. White: you should have stayed out of "the deep water" - part 1


Still trying to 'catch-up' on what transpired over the internet during my grandson's recent visit; the following thread posted by Ken Temple on the Beggars All blog caught my attention:


[Original online posting of the Vimeo video: No Co Ever: Episode  1]

In the written portion of the post, Ken penned:

I agree with everything these gentleman said on the issues of doctrine and the problems with the Elephant Room 2

. . . except for one small side comment that Carl Trueman made that I think is important for Christians to understand.

Ken then expounds on the "one small comment", stating:

When talking about the Christians at the Council of Nicea in 325 AD, Professor Trueman said they were Turks. [around the 31 minute mark] Professor Trueman was right that the men at the Council of Nicea were not "white men", but they were not Turkish either. They were Greeks and Egyptians and Syrians (The Syrians before the Arabs conquered them in the 600s AD.) That is an amazing mistake by a church history professor, in my opinion. They were mostly Greeks, Syrians, 2 Latins from Rome, and Egyptians (Athanasius, for one) and others from around the Roman Empire. The Turks did not live in what is today called Turkey at the time of the Council of Nicea. The Turks (Seljuk and Ottomans) did not come to that land until before the Crusades (1071 AD) and they did not completely conquer the area known as Anatolia and Constantinople until 1453 AD. No Turks lived in these areas in the New Testament days nor in early church history until the 900s AD!

Apart from some particulars concerning the ethnic and geographical background of some of the bishops that attended "the Council of Nicea in 325 AD", Ken has been pretty accurate in his above assessment, though he appears to be unaware of some background information that seems to qualify Carl's remark in the video (see THIS LINK for Carl's article, "Gnosticism, Nicea and Celebrity").

But, this post is not about going to focus on the ethnic and geographical background of the bishops that attended the Council of Nicea in 325 AD, rather, it will build upon, "everything these gentleman said on the issues of doctrine", which Ken stated that he "agree[s] with".

Pastor Mike Abendroth, the host of the program that Ken linked to, near the beginning of the NCE-E1 video, states:

What is a 'kook and a Barney'? Well 'kooks and Barneys' are people who try to surf with experts, and they'll try to paddle in, out in the water, and they just get in the way of the surfers';  and they are known by the locals as 'kooks and Barneys'—they're in over their head, they're playing in the deep water. So I would like to offer a 'kooks and Barneys award'; and so, today, we are going to offer that award, not to a particular person, but to a group of people, and would be the organizers of The Elephant Room. (2:40 ff.)

[For information on "The Elephant Room", go to their OFFICIAL WEBSITE]

Now, I am going to 'play-on' Mike's theme of 'kooks and Barneys' a bit, for I think it will become apparent that at least one of the members of the panel of 'experts' in the video is probably "over their head", "playing in deep water"...

In the NCE-E1 video, at approximately the 6:20ff mark, James White said:

I really think what we're dealing with here—uhh um, and this, this may be more in, uhh, in, in the good Doctor Trueman's area to comment on—but, as, as I have had the opportunity to teach Church history in the past, and also joining to that working as an apologist, it seems to me that at different periods in Church history, the clarity that we gain on particular topics is due to the struggles that the Church is facing...

And a bit later at 7:14 ff.:

In the early Church, as was mentioned before, the difference between homoousios and homoiousios is, is a HUGE gap, but it is only one letter...

Is that an accurate statement? Note what St. Athansius, the great defender of the Nicene Creed and Trinitarianism, had to say:

Those who deny the Council altogether, are sufficiently exposed by these brief remarks ; those, however, who accept everything else that was defined at Nicaea, and doubt only about the Coessential [homoousios], must not be treated as enemies ; nor do we here attack them as Ariomaniacs, nor as opponents of the Fathers, but we discuss the matter with them as brothers with brothers, who mean what we mean, and dispute about one word. For, confessing that the Son is from the essence of the Father, and not from other subsistence, and that He is not a creature nor work, but His genuine and natural offspring, and that He is eternally with the Father as being His Word and Wisdom, they are not far from accepting even the phrase, 'Coessential' [homoousios]...But since they say that He is 'of the essence' and 'Like-in-essence,' [homoiousios] what do they signify by these but 'Coessential?' [homoousios] (De Synodis - Councils of Arminum and Seleucia), 41 - NPNF 4.472.) 

A "HUGE gap" in the early Church ???; I, and St. Athansius, think not.

A bit later, Mike reads off the questions that Mark Driscoll presented to T. D. Jakes, all of which Jakes' answered in the affirmative. James White then jumps in with:

But before that, before those questions, Jakes had provided the absolutely necessary redefinition from a non-Trinitarian modalistic perspective, which was when asked initially about the existence of three divine persons, his response was, 'I can go there, but that's not my favorite way of saying it; that doesn't do it for me'. Well when someone starts talking about the ancient creeds of the Church and says, 'that doesn't do it for me, I want to know why. And when you go back into his teaching before this, he is consistently used the language of manifestations, he has said that there is one God, but different manifestation, going to a major textual variant in 1 Timothy 3:16 where, uhh, God was manifect in the flesh—even though the earliest reading, the manuscripts, He was manifest in the flesh—but leaving that to, to, uhh, to the side, Oneness Pentecostals, Jesus only Pentecostals, uhh, teach that Jesus was literally two persons...

James White does not know what he is talking about here, Oneness Pentecostals DO NOT teach, "that Jesus was literally two persons".

From the United Pentecostal Church International website (the largest Oneness Pentecostal denomination) we read:

The Oneness of God

God is absolutely and indivisibly one (Deuteronomy 6:4; Galatians 3:20). In Jesus dwells all the fullness of the Godhead bodily (Colossians 2:9). He is the self-revelation of the one God, the incarnation of the full, undivided Godhead (John 20:28; I Timothy 3:16).

God has revealed Himself as Father (in parental relationship to humanity), in the Son (in human flesh), and as the Holy Spirit (in spiritual action). (See Deuteronomy 32:6 and Isaiah 63:16; Luke 1:35 and Galatians 4:4; Genesis 1:2 and Acts 1:8.) The one God existed as Father, Word, and Spirit before His incarnation as Jesus Christ, the Son of God; and while Jesus walked on earth as God Himself incarnate, the Spirit of God continued to be omnipresent. However, the Bible does not teach that there are three distinct centers of consciousness in the Godhead or that Jesus is one of three divine persons.

Jesus is true God and true man as one divine-human person. We can distinguish these two aspects of Christ’s identity, but we cannot separate them. The Incarnation joined the fullness of deity to complete humanity. (Link - bold emphasis mine.)

Dr. Gregory A. Boyd in his critical book, Oneness Pentecostals & The Trinity, 'gets it right':

And yet, Oneness Pentecostals insist, Jesus was only one person. If he appears to be more than that, if the Father and Son appear to be more than distinct "natures" and rather appear in the Gospels as actual distinct "persons," this can only be an illusion assumed for the sake of revelation. (Page 35.)

James White not only misrepresents the Oneness Pentecostals, he also misrepresents the modalism that existed in the early Church:

So the prayers of Jesus—this is not technically, exactly like what Sabellius had it; there were different forms of dynamic monarchianism, and things like that in ancient Church history...(12:46 ff.)

Sabellius DID NOT teach any of the "different forms of dynamic monarchianism, and things like that in ancient Church history"; fact is, Sabellius was a modalist monarchian. (FYI: Oneness Pentecostals ARE NOT dynamic monarchians, they are modalistic monarchians).

Much more to cover, but it will have to wait until part 2.


Grace and peace,

David

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

A new systematic theology now online for reading and/or download


Last week, through Sunday, I had my 11 year grandson staying at the beach, and spent very little time on the internet; as such, I am playing 'catch-up' in cyberspace concerning my personal areas of interest.

Earlier today, I found that Drake Shelton back on August 24th, 2012 has made available online his 2nd edition of: Systematic Theology - A Complete Orthodox Protestant and Scripturalist Body of Divinity (LINK).

Because I am still working my way through Michael Horton's The Christian Faith - A Systematic Theology for Pilgrims On the Way, I have not yet read Drake's work, and hope to do so later this week; but, given what I have read of Drake's works on theology, I am reasonable sure that his book will yield some substantial contributions.


Grace and peace,

David

Friday, August 17, 2012

I am a bit embarrassed to admit...


OK, perhaps "embarrassed" is hyperbolic, but I am somewhat surprised that I 'missed' the publication of the following three documents (which I 'discovered' via the reading of Benedict XVI's April 20th, 2012 full message - LINK):

Verbum Domini (Benedict XVI's 2008 Post-Synodal Apostolic Exhortation) - HTML version; PDF version

Instrumentum Laboris (The Word of God In The Life And Mission Of The Church) - HTML version; PDF version

Lineamenta (The Word of God In The Life And Mission Of The Church) - HTML version; PDF version

So far, I have only 'skimmed' through these lengthy documents, but hope to engage in a more thorough reading this weekend, the Lord willing. May have a post(s) on these in the future...


Grace and peace,

David

Thursday, August 16, 2012

A Provocative post...


I must confess upfront, that I am anything but passionate about politics. This does not mean that I have not seriously considered the nature/role Christians are to play in the world that we live; but rather, that my explorations into this topic have left me at this time somewhat 'neutral' (my studies into this issue have ranged between libertarianism and theonomy).  With that said, I found the following post to be a bit more than interesting (I am providing the opening portion of the post here—go to the link for the entire thread):


The Worldview of Romney and Ryan and the 2012 Presidential Election

Romney and Ryan are the first non-Protestant combination Presidential and Vice-Presidential ticket in the history of American elections. America has been characteristically a Baptist/Protestant country, much of which stems from what was left in Europe. This flies in the face of a national history-long trend. I actually don't think that President Obama and Vice President Biden are Protestant and Catholic, but some kind of quasi-humanism/religious liberalism, but the President claims to be Protestant.

Both Romney and Ryan come from a top-down hierarchical religious structure that belies their states rights, power to the people, economic freedom paradigm. In modern colloquial terms, what's up with that? Why are we so sure now that the Mormon president or the Pope won't be telling our candidates what to do, say in the vein of that for what John F. Kennedy had to answer for in the 1960 presidential election? I've been thinking about this recently and let me give you my take. I think I'm right, but I'm open to your thoughts. (
LINK)


Grace and peace,

David